Who won when Atlassian bought Loom?

Investors Insights

Yesterday, Atlassian announced that it would be buying Loom for $975M in cash.

With a last round valuation of $1.5 billion, was this a bad exit?

Let's take a look at who wins, who loses, and who breaks even.

🌱 Early 2016: Series Seed 2 Preferred ($0.15/sh, $622K)
- Best guess: Friends & Fam, Angels

🌱 Oct 2016: Series Seed 1 Preferred ($0.37/sh, $3.1M)
- First VC $$ from 1517 Fund

☘ Nov 2018: Series A Preferred ($0.74/sh, $11M)
- Showtime! Ilya Fushman at Kleiner Perkins leads the round and takes a Board Seat

🌳 Oct 2019: Series B Preferred ($2.08/sh, $28M)
Andrew Reed at Sequoia Capital leads the round and takes a Board Seat

⏸ Quick intermission.

From corporate filings, the Board is now 5 people: 3 for Common Stock (likely the 3 co-founders of Loom: Vinay HiremathJoe ThomasShahed K.), 1 on behalf of Series A Preferred (Kleiner), and 1 on behalf of Series B Preferred (Sequoia). This will matter later.

⏯ Alright, onwards:

🌵 May 2020: Series B+ Preferred ($3.94/sh, $23.5M)
- 2x price increase, 2 months into COVID? Makes sense given the movement to remote work.

🌲 May 2021: Series C Preferred ($16.19/sh, $130M)
- ZIRP time! Andreessen Horowitz comes in with a major valuation step-up (to $1.5B). 🚩 a16z does *not* get a board seat.

📜 Let's now take a quick look at the cap table:

Common Stock: ~45M shares, 45%
Seed 1: 4.3M shares, 4%
Seed 2: 8.4M shares, 8%
Series A: 14.4M shares, 15%
Series B: 13.5M shares, 14%
Series B+: 5.9M shares, 6%
Series C: 8M shares, 8%

👏 Kudos to the Loom team for:

💧Limiting liquidation preference (all Preferred Stock has standard 1x pref.)
💼 Board Control (founders have 3 of the 5 seats).

🔻Then comes 2022: war + inflation + tech plunges.

🌅 But, it's always darkest before the dawn.

⏩ Fast-forward to today. BAM! A $975M sale.

👍 Why this exit was a good one:

#1 Comparable transactions

At EquityZen we've seen a ~45% discount on secondary transactions recently. Loom sold the whole pie (not just a slice), at a 35% discount to their 2021 round.

#2 Great returns for *almost* all their investors.
- Seed 1: 64x
- Seed 2: 25x
- Series A: 12.5x
- Series B: 4.5x
- Series B+: 2.3x
- Series C: 1.0x

#3 $400M for founders + current/former employees (#tendies).
Assume ~10% of the total proceeds (~$100M) went to current and former employees (do you call them Loomers? Loominites? Loomineers? okay i'm done). That means $300M for the 3 founders. 💰

🤔 So, how did this deal get done?

Corporate governance.

When the founders control the Board, they can say "Yes" to the $975M dress 👗. When you FOMO pump $130M into the company at the market peak of '21 and don't get a board seat (which is what a16z did), then, in the wise words of the Hamilton musical, "You don't have the votes" 🎶

But, because of a 1x liquidation preference, a16z still gets its money back (rather than taking a 33% loss).

🏁 Big win for the founders, current/former employees, and almost all investors. What do you think?

 


Screenshot 2024-02-20 at 2.39.43 PM

Interested in exploring the private companies trading on EquityZen's marketplace?

Sign Up

 

Related Posts

The Wall Street Journal: How Wall Street Middlemen Help Silicon Valley Employees Cash In Early

The Wall Street Journal highlights the nascent secondary market for private company shares. Atish Davda, EquityZen CEO...

WSJ: Startup Workers Wrestle With Stock Options as Company Exits Stall

Startups give workers stock options instead of a higher salary and as a bet on the young venture’s future. But the...

What is the Private Secondary Market?

From stocks, to bonds, to commodities and more, most investors are familiar with the various options when it comes to...